Posted: 10/03/2020

Top retailers announced at Shop of the Year awards

From left, John Farrand of the Guild of Fine Food, Guy Tullberg of The Tracklement Company and Simon MacDonnell from Papadeli, winner of delicatessen and grocer of the year

Papadeli, The Courtyard Dairy and Jarrold were among the winners at the Guild of Fine Food’s Shop of the Year awards 2020, announced in Harrogate, Yorkshire on Monday, 9th March.

Mezze, a Middle Eastern-inspired specialist food and drink shop in Waterford, Ireland, scooped the award in the newcomer category, while Farndon Fields of Market Harborough was judged to be the best farm shop in the nation.

Taking top honours in the specialist food or drink shop category was London-based Andreas of Chelsea Green. 

After a team of experts spent months visiting finalists up and down the country on the hunt for the very best independent retailers, the winners were announced at Fodder Farm Shop and Café in Harrogate.

Two rounds of judging, including a scheduled visit from a judge and an unannounced mystery shopper, whittled down the entries to reveal the top retailers in each category.

Winner of the specialist cheese shop gong, The Courtyard Dairy demonstrated a “dedication to cheese with no compromise on sourcing,” said judges, and they also praised owner, Andy Swinscoe’s “sense of adventure” and ethos.

A family-run business opened in 1985 by Kevin and Milly Stokes, Farndon Fields impressed with its range of quality local products, and is, according to judges, a creative, vibrant and inspiring farm shop.

Andreas of Chelsea Green, winner of specialist food and drink shop category, was applauded for its “honesty, integrity and palpable passion”, while deli and grocer of the year, Papadeli, charmed the judges with its “general ambience” and range of homemade cakes.

Having been trading for less than two years, Mezze was commended for its “warmth” and the “passion” of owners Nicola and Dvir, as well as the diversity and quality of its offering, much of which is made on site, while Jarrold also received high praise for its own-brand products created by local producers.

The panel of judges, which included Edward Berry of The Flying Fork, Stuart Gates, former managing director at Fortnum & Mason and senior buyer at Harrods, award-winning retailer Tracey Colley and food writer, Patrick McGuigan, rated, scored and provided feedback on every aspect of the shops before agreeing on overall category winners.

Shop of the Year 2020 winners and runners up

Delicatessen & Grocer sponsored by The Tracklement Company

Papadeli, Bristol

181 Delicatessen, Edinburgh

Farm Shop (farmer owned) sponsored by Peter’s Yard

(L-R) John Farrand, Guild of Fine Food, Adam Tynan from Peter’s Yard, Nicola Stokes and Milly Stokes of Farndon Fields Farm Shop

Farndon Fields Farm Shop, Market Harborough, Leicestershire

Robertshaw’s Farm Shop, Bradford, West Yorkshire

Food Hall sponsored by Le Gruyere AOP

(L-R) John Farrand, Guild of Fine Food, Judith Finney from Jarrold and Helen Daysh from Le Gruyère AOP

Jarrold, Norwich, Norfolk

The Barn at Severn & Wye, Westbury-on-Severn, Gloucestershire 

Specialist Cheese Shop sponsored by Le Gruyere AOP

(L-R) John Farrand, Guild of Fine Food, Kathy Swinscoe and Fiona Robinson from The Courtyard Dairy and Helen Daysh from Le Gruyère AOP

The Courtyard Dairy, Austwick, North Yorkshire

The Pangbourne Cheese Shop, Reading, Berkshire

Specialist Food or Drink Shop sponsored by Le Gruyere AOP

(L-R) John Farrand, Guild of Fine Food, Shop of the Year judge, Stuart Gates and Helen Daysh from Le Gruyère AOP

Andreas of Chelsea Green, London

Latimer’s Seafood, Whitburn, Tyne & Wear

Newcomer Award sponsored by Fine Food Digest

(L-R) John Farrand, Guild of Fine Food, Shop of the Year judge, Tracey Colley and Michael Lane, Fine Food Digest

Mezze, Waterford, Ireland

Return to the top